Shipmates,
If you know me at all well mates, you know that I have a fair and open mind that I bring to bear whilst judging the literary merits of popular fiction. Certainly, I’ve had some harsh words for the Rowlings and Browns of the world, but with due cause. The educated citizen well knows that these “authors” march at the fore of the philistine phalanx intent on tearing down the walls of erudite society, unfurling the sacred scrolls and besmearing the best that’s been said or written with their Tom Clancyesque babel! In many ways, having tasted of the fruits of our cultural legacy, I’m left in a fearful position: forever wishing to shore up the all-too-porous barriers that keep the frenzied masses at bay—their cries of “team Jacob” and “team Edward” an affront to even the most feeble-minded street urchin with any respect at all for the glories of language—I’m forced by the cruel vagaries of quotidian necessity to lower the trowel of learning and take up the sledge of ignorance in order to earn my own humble crust. That’s right shipmates, I, your humble narrator, find myself often “recommending” the likes of John Grisham, Debbie MacComber, and Danielle Steel!
Well, let it not be said that Ian is a snob; a man of dignity and taste perhaps, but not a haughty patrician with nose upturned at the sight of my less-fortunate brethren struggling to cobble together an interesting thought using their meager, underdeveloped mental faculties! If my thread is to be shuttled into the deep recesses of the ignorant, I wait on bended knees for my fate. In fact, rather than stand out as the sole thread of deepest vermillion in an otherwise muted and matching field of brown, I’ve decided to immerse the fabric of my learned mind in the muddy ink of the common herd of humanity if only to better know the guests whose service is my profession.
To this estimable end, I’ve decided to launch upon a course of popular reading to augment my usual literary gleanings. I’ve started with David Baldacci’s “One Summer.” To be kind, it was a quick read. In short, Baldacci’s novel is the sentimental tale of a man dying from some unnamed illness whose wife tragically perishes while running to fetch his pain meds on an icy Christmas Eve. Rather than succumb to said illness, our hero miraculously recovers, regains the custody of his three children, and moves to his wife’s decrepit childhood home. There is much to be recommended here: the book is printed on a thin yet fibrous paper that would make an excellent fuel with which to start a fire on a cold winter’s night. The literary merits are not quite as pleasant. The following exchange, between father and daughter after said daughter has confessed to betraying her father, should demonstrate my point aptly:
“Will you ever be able to forgive me? To trust me again?”
He touched her cheek. “I do, on both counts.”
“Why?”
“Something called unconditional love, honey.”
I ask you, by what generous stretch of the imagination can we consider this literature? Does our proud, albeit distant, boreal cousin deserve to sacrifice his* life so that a travesty such as this can show its ugly face? Evil demon of public taste! Why do you mock me? And yet, why rail against the ever-eroding tides of ignorance? Have I not proclaimed my own acquiescence to the hand of fate? Like Ahab, I have seen the whale-tied Parsee, augury of my own fate, dragged down to his inglorious end!** Avast! Up with the harpoon of basest ignorance! I too shall land my barb in the flesh of marketplace success! The ripest clichés shall turn to gold under the stroke of my eager fingers! To the typewriters men!
*Are trees gendered? Perhaps if any plant biologists stumble upon these words, they might chime in with some clarification.
** Also known as the New York Times Bestseller List.